Ask the Expert

Print this page Bookmark and Share

Topic: parents

Question: If you have been diagnosed with a level 3 concussion what does that really mean? Is one week long enough to stay away from sports if they have no signs of problems? No additional headache and had no motor or cognitive problems the night the player was injured.

Answer: Grading concussions is fraught with difficulties because different scales are used and the 'grade' of concussion in most instances has little bearing on how the person recovers. Many scales describe Grade 3 as any loss of consciousness. Amnesia and persistent symptoms are more important, based on recent studies. Without a doubt, an athlete with any 'grade' of concussion should not return to play until ALL symptoms are resolved, including headache, dizziness, nausea, concentration problems, emotional problems and fatigue. The athlete must remain symptom-free at the level of exertion necessitated by the sport he or she in playing. In most instances, clearance by a knowledgeable health care provider is recommended, to be absolutely sure the athlete is symptom-free and has a normal examination. Premature return to play increases the risk for more concussions and can, very rarely, even lead to death. The younger the athlete, the more cautious one must be. In short, if your athlete is free of symptoms (both at rest and with exertion, has a normal examination and has not had other recent concussions, he or she can return to play. But remember that evidence suggests that the impact of repeat concussions is significant, so prevention of further concussions is very important.

Answered on 01-01-1995 by Todd Maugans, MD, pediatric neurosurgeon, Dayton Children's

View more questions by topic, or to search through all "Ask an Expert" questions.


Visit our blog!

Visit the Dr. Mom Squad blog to join in the conversation with our experts! You will hear from four local women who have two big things in common; they are all doctors and they are all moms! Hear what they have to say on the latest kids health issues and learn tips on how you can help keep your kids stay healthy and safe!


  • Hand washing Know how to best clean your hands to prevent the cold and flu!
  • Sleep Make sure your child is getting enough sleep.
  • Green cleaning Do you know how to reduce allergy and asthma triggers by cleaning green?
  • Heat related illness Make sure your young athlete avoids the dangers of heat!

Free parenting enewsletter

Finding trusted child health and safety information doesn't have to be hard. eGrowing Together offers the latest health, safety and parenting information from our experts delivered to your inbox every month.

Sign up now!

Stay Connected

Find us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Visit Our Blog Youtube Caring Bridge

Upcoming Events

Get your family started on a healthy lifestyle

Join the Beavercreek TWIG groups 11, 17, and 22 for the annual spring luncheon, Run for the Roses, on April 26, 2014 at the Beavercreek Golf Club.

City of Sidney police and Sidney YMCA Healthy Kids Day

Darke County YMCA is sponsoring a Healthy Kids Day on April 26, 2014 fro 12:00 pm until 4:00 pm.

View full event calendarView full event calendar

Health and Safety

Your child's health and safety is our top priority


The Children's Medical Center of Dayton Dayton Children's
The Right Care for the Right Reasons

One Children's Plaza - Dayton, Ohio - 45404-1815