Questions from a child: Why does my brother hate me so much?

Print this page Bookmark and Share

By Gregory Ramey, PhD, child psychologist at Dayton Children's and Dayton Daily News columnist

Edition: March 21, 2010 | Topic: Questions from readers

Question:

I wonder if you would help a kid? Can you help me to get my 12-year-old brother to like me?

I’m 10 and he tells me all the time how much he hates me because I was born a girl. He tells me everything I do is awful or stupid, no matter how hard I try to please him. He calls me terrible names in front of my friends that make fun of my being a girl like, “Little bra.” I just don’t know how I can live in my house after I get my period. I dread it! Sometimes I think my life will be over!

My brother is so mean, and not just to me. He fights with other boys. He kills birds and other animals while he laughs. He also starts fires on people’s porches to scare them (grownups). When he gets really made at me, he says he’s going to take off my clothes in front of his friends. I get frightened and run to lock myself in the bathroom. When I try to tell my parents, they yell at me for being a tattletale or for crying over spilled milk.

I asked my priest what to do and he said to “pray.” I say a rosary for him every day and even lit a novena for a week. But even God doesn’t listen. I know if I just got my brother to like me, he would be nice to me and I could get him to be nice to other people and the animals and not start fires anymore. So what should I do? All I do is cry, and bat my head against the wall, and cry more and more.

Answer:

The problem is not how to get your brother to like you, but rather how to get professional help for your brother. The things he is doing are not normal. Killing animals, starting fires, and threatening to undress you are all signs that he has a serious mental problem. His problems have nothing to do with you. You are not at fault.

You did the right thing in speaking with your priest and to your mom, but they both gave you bad advice. If you told them the things you told me, they should have recognized that this is a serious problem that requires them to do something other than advise you to pray or to stop being a tattletale. They made a mistake. They may not have understood the seriousness of your brother’s problems.

You now need to be strong enough to ask for the help of another adult. How about the mom or dad of a good friend or a teacher at school? Please be sure that you tell the adult all the things that you wrote in the letter so that your brother will get the help he needs before he hurts anyone seriously.

Please write me back and let me know how things worked out.

PDF Version


Dr. Ramey Gregory Ramey, PhD, is a child psychologist and vice president for outpatient services at The Children's Medical Center of Dayton. For more of his columns, visit www.childrensdayton.org/ramey and join Dr. Ramey on facebook at http://www.facebook.com/drgregramey

©2010 The Children's Medical Center of Dayton. Columns may be reproduced with the permission of Dayton Children's.


 

Visit our blog!

Visit the Dr. Mom Squad blog to join in the conversation with our experts! You will hear from four local women who have two big things in common; they are all doctors and they are all moms!

Kohl's Cares® Merchandise

Every season, Kohl's offers special items for sale with all profits donated to children's hospitals – including Dayton Children’s. You can view the entire collection of stuffed animals, books and much more at Kohl's Cares® Merchandise.

Free parenting enewsletter

Finding trusted child health and safety information doesn't have to be hard. eGrowing Together offers the latest health, safety and parenting information from our experts delivered to your inbox every month.

Sign up now!

Stay Connected

Find us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Visit Our Blog Youtube Caring Bridge

 

Upcoming Events

Feel free to bring a covered dish to share

Car Seat Safety Check

For a fun night of playing games and having a good time, families are encouraged to bring any board games, card games or other fun games to play. Pizza and beverages provided. Feel free to bring a snack or dessert to share.

Car Seat Safety Check

View full event calendarView full event calendar

Health and Safety

Your child's health and safety is our top priority

Accreditations

The Children's Medical Center of Dayton Dayton Children's
The Right Care for the Right Reasons

One Children's Plaza - Dayton, Ohio - 45404-1815
937-641-3000
www.childrensdayton.org